Best Pizza Spots in NYC You Need to Try in 2025

The Best Pizza Spots in NYC You Need to Try in 2025

Published on April 11, 2025

Looking for the best pizza spots NYC 2025 has to offer? New York City is the pizza capital of the world, with a slice on nearly every corner—but not all pies are created equal. From iconic classics to hidden gems, this guide rounds up the top pizza places in NYC to try this year. Whether you’re craving a thin-crust New York slice, a Neapolitan pie, or a Sicilian square, our NYC pizza guide 2025 will lead you to the best spots across the city. Plus, we’ll share local directories to plan your perfect pizza day, from post-pizza drinks to fun activities. Let’s dive into the ultimate list of NYC’s must-try pizza spots!

Why NYC Is the Pizza Capital of the World

NYC’s pizza legacy dates back to 1905 with the opening of Lombardi’s in Little Italy, often credited as America’s first pizzeria. Since then, the city has perfected every style—New York’s thin, foldable slices, Neapolitan pies with charred crusts, and Sicilian squares with a thick, doughy base. With over 32,000 pizza shops in the city, according to web data, NYC offers endless options. But we’ve narrowed it down to the best, focusing on quality, authenticity, and local favorites that stand out in 2025.

The Best Pizza Spots in NYC for 2025

Here’s our curated list of the best pizza spots NYC 2025, spanning Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx, and beyond.

1. L’Industrie Pizzeria – Williamsburg

Location: 254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

L’Industrie Pizzeria in Williamsburg tops our list for its perfect New York-style slices, often hailed as the best single slice in NYC. Their blistered, thin crust—made with a long fermentation process—crunches like fresh bread, topped with imported Italian ingredients like velvety burrata, giant basil leaves, and grated Parmesan. The pepperoni slice is a must-try, with a slightly sweet kick. After your slice, explore more Brooklyn eats with the NYC Best Korean BBQ Restaurants Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: High-quality ingredients, perfect crust, and a signature burrata slice.
• Price: Slices start at $4.

2. Una Pizza Napoletana – Lower East Side

Location: 175 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002

Una Pizza Napoletana in the Lower East Side was crowned the best pizzeria in the world by 50 Top Pizza in 2024, and it’s still a top contender in 2025. Chef Anthony Mangieri’s naturally leavened, wood-fired Neapolitan pies are made with precision, featuring a chewy crust and simple, high-quality toppings like San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella. Reservations are a must, as this spot is only open Thursday to Saturday. After your meal, unwind at a nearby bar with the NYC Rooftop Bars and Happy Hours Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: World-class Neapolitan pizza, artisanal ingredients, and a legacy of excellence.
• Price: Pies start at $25.

3. Louie & Ernie’s Pizza – The Bronx

Location: 1300 Crosby Ave, Bronx, NY 10461

Louie & Ernie’s in the Schuylerville section of the Bronx has been a neighborhood staple since 1959, serving New York-style pies with a soft middle and crispy edges. Their sausage-topped pizza, with its crumbly, salty flavor, is a fan favorite. This tiny spot in a white frame house offers both slices and whole pies, plus a variety of calzones. After your pizza, explore more Bronx activities with the NYC Free & Cheap Events Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: Classic New York-style pizza, iconic sausage topping, and a true neighborhood vibe.
• Price: Slices start at $3.50.

4. Mama’s Too – Upper West Side & West Village

Location: 2750 Broadway, New York, NY 10025 (UWS); 95 7th Ave S, New York, NY 10014 (West Village)

Mama’s Too has become an NYC classic, with locations on the Upper West Side and in the West Village. Their gas-oven Sicilian squares are a standout, especially the mushroom pie and the cacio e pepe with four cheeses and cracked black pepper. The square pepperoni slice is worth a trip across the city. After your meal, grab a coffee nearby with the NYC Coffee Shops & Cafes Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: Inventive Sicilian squares, bold flavors, and a local favorite.
• Price: Slices start at $4.

5. Rubirosa – Nolita

Location: 235 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012

Rubirosa in Nolita is a top Italian restaurant known for its Staten Island-style, crackery crust pies. The vodka-sauce and tie-dye varieties are must-tries, and they even offer a stellar gluten-free option. This sit-down spot is perfect for a date night or group dinner. After dining, catch a comedy show in the area with the NYC Comedy Clubs Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: Unique Staten Island-style crust, creative pies, and a cozy atmosphere.
• Price: Pies start at $20.

6. L&B Spumoni Gardens – Bensonhurst

Location: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223

L&B Spumoni Gardens in Bensonhurst has been serving Sicilian-style square pies since 1939. Their signature style—dough, mozzarella, then sauce, with a dusting of Romano cheese—creates a unique, cheesy bite with a crusty edge. The outdoor seating makes it a great spot for groups. After your pizza, relax at a nearby spa with the NYC Spa Clubs Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: Iconic Sicilian squares, outdoor seating, and a Brooklyn staple.
• Price: Slices start at $3.50.

7. John’s of Bleecker Street – Greenwich Village

Location: 278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014

John’s of Bleecker Street, a Greenwich Village institution since 1929, serves coal-oven-fired, thin-crust pies with a perfect char. They don’t sell slices—only whole pies—so bring a friend to share classics like the Margherita or a pie with sliced meatballs. After your meal, explore vegan dining options nearby with the NYC Vegan Restaurants Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: Historic coal-oven pizza, old-school vibe, and no-slices policy for a true pie experience.
• Price: Pies start at $18.

8. Joe’s Pizza – Multiple Locations

Location: 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014 (Greenwich Village); 1435 Broadway, New York, NY 10018 (Times Square)

Joe’s Pizza is the quintessential NYC slice spot, with locations in Greenwich Village, Times Square, and beyond. Since 1975, they’ve been serving thin, foldable New York slices with a near-perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio. The plain cheese slice is a classic, but the pepperoni is a crowd-pleaser. After your slice, play a game of pickleball with the NYC Pickleball Courts Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: Iconic New York slice, consistent quality, and tourist-friendly locations.
• Price: Slices start at $3.

9. Di Fara Pizza – Midwood

Location: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230

Di Fara Pizza in Midwood is a pilgrimage spot for pizza lovers, despite the passing of its legendary owner, Domenico “Dom” DeMarco, in 2022. The family continues to churn out precise New York-style slices with a crisp crust, fresh basil, and a balance of sauce and cheese. The regular slice is a classic, but the Sicilian is also a favorite. After your visit, enjoy a classic diner meal with the NYC Diners Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: A New York pizza legend, fresh ingredients, and a storied history.
• Price: Slices start at $5.

10. Scarr’s Pizza – Lower East Side

Location: 35 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002

Scarr’s Pizza in the Lower East Side is a modern classic, known for its house-milled flour that creates a light, airy crust. Their New York-style slices are topped with organic ingredients, and the throwback decor—wood paneling and neon signs—adds to the vibe. The plain cheese slice is a standout, but the pepperoni is a close second. After your pizza, explore outdoor dining options with the NYC Outdoor Dining Directory.

• Why It’s a Must-Try: House-milled flour, retro atmosphere, and high-quality slices.
• Price: Slices start at $4.

Tips for Enjoying Pizza in NYC

Here are some tips to make the most of your pizza journey in NYC:

• Try Different Styles: Sample New York-style slices, Neapolitan pies, and Sicilian squares to experience the city’s diversity.
• Visit Off-Peak Hours: Popular spots like L’Industrie and Una Pizza Napoletana can have long lines, so go early or late to avoid the rush.
• Plan Your Day: Use directories like the NYC Emergency Services & Healthcare Directory to ensure you’re prepared for a full day of exploring.

Final Thoughts: Your 2025 NYC Pizza Adventure

NYC’s pizza scene in 2025 is a delicious blend of history and innovation, with spots like L’Industrie, Una Pizza Napoletana, and Louie & Ernie’s leading the way. Whether you’re folding a classic slice at Joe’s or savoring a Neapolitan pie at Rubirosa, this NYC pizza guide 2025 ensures you’ll find the perfect spot. Explore these top pizza places in NYC to try, and use our directories to plan your day—whether it’s dining, relaxing, or having fun in the city!

What’s your favorite pizza spot in NYC? Share your recommendations in the comments below, and follow us on Twitter/X for more NYC lifestyle guides!