Where to Grab a Burger Like In-N-Out During in 2025

Where to Grab a Burger Like In-N-Out During the NYC Marathon 2025

Published on April 11, 2025

Running or cheering at the NYC Marathon on Sunday, November 2, 2025, and craving a burger that hits like an In-N-Out Double-Double? The NYC Marathon, one of the world’s largest races, draws over 50,000 runners and countless spectators, winding through all five boroughs from Staten Island to Central Park. But here’s the catch: In-N-Out Burger, the West Coast cult favorite, isn’t available in NYC due to its strict expansion policies, sticking to states like California, Texas, and soon Tennessee. Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered with the best burgers in NYC during Marathon 2025 that capture In-N-Out’s fresh, simple, and affordable vibe. Whether you’re a runner refueling after mile 26 or a spectator cheering along the route, these In-N-Out style burgers in NYC will satisfy your cravings. We’ve mapped out spots near the Marathon route, from Brooklyn to Manhattan, and linked to our NYC Diners Directory for more burger-adjacent dining options. Let’s dive into this Marathon burger guide!

Why In-N-Out Isn’t in NYC (And What to Do About It)

In-N-Out Burger, founded in 1948 in California, is known for its fresh, never-frozen patties, simple menu, and budget-friendly prices. But the chain only operates within a day’s drive of its distribution centers, with the easternmost locations currently in Texas and soon Tennessee—still far from NYC. That hasn’t stopped New Yorkers from craving its iconic Double-Double, especially during high-energy events like the NYC Marathon. With the Marathon route stretching from Staten Island through Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and finishing in Manhattan’s Central Park, you’ll need a quick, satisfying bite to keep your energy up. These burger spots along the route offer the closest thing to an In-N-Out experience in NYC, with fresh ingredients, casual vibes, and prices that won’t break the bank.

Best In-N-Out-Style Burgers Along the NYC Marathon Route

Here’s a curated list of burger spots in NYC that capture the In-N-Out vibe, strategically located near the 2025 NYC Marathon route for runners and spectators alike.

1. 7th Street Burger – East Village (Near Mile 9 in Brooklyn)

Location: 91 E 7th St, New York, NY 10009

As the Marathon crosses from Brooklyn into Manhattan around mile 9, 7th Street Burger in the East Village is a top pick for an In-N-Out-style burger. Known for its smashed patties with roughly-chopped onions pressed into the beef, this spot offers a cheeseburger for $8 that’s reminiscent of In-N-Out’s simple, salty goodness. The gooey American cheese and soft bun make it a perfect post-Brooklyn refuel. After your burger, catch a comedy show nearby with the NYC Comedy Clubs Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Smashed patties, fresh ingredients, and a no-frills vibe.
• Pro Tip: Add extra sauce for an Animal Style-inspired twist.

2. Petey’s Burger – Astoria (Near Mile 14 in Queens)

Location: 30-05 30th Ave, Astoria, NY 11102

At mile 14, as runners cross the Queensboro Bridge into Queens, Petey’s Burger in Astoria is a local favorite often cited as an In-N-Out copycat. Their double cheeseburger, starting at $7, features thin patties, fresh veggies, and a thousand island-like dressing that mimics In-N-Out’s spread. It’s a quick, affordable stop for spectators in Queens. After your meal, explore vegan dining options with the NYC Vegan Restaurants Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Thin patties, fresh toppings, and a similar dressing.
• Pro Tip: Their fries are better than In-N-Out’s—crisp and well-seasoned.

3. Harlem Shake – Harlem (Near Mile 22 in Manhattan)

Location: 100 W 124th St, New York, NY 10027

By mile 22, runners are in Harlem, and Harlem Shake offers a top-notch smashburger that rivals In-N-Out’s simplicity. Their “Hot Mess” burger, priced at $9, features crispy-edged patties with pickled cherry pepper-bacon relish, American cheese, and a soft bun. It’s a great spot for spectators cheering near the route’s northern stretch. After your burger, grab a coffee nearby with the NYC Coffee Shops & Cafes Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Smashed patties and a focus on fresh, simple flavors.
• Pro Tip: Pair it with their thick-cut fries for a full meal.

4. Schnipper’s – Midtown (Near Mile 24 in Manhattan)

Location: 620 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018

As the Marathon route heads south through Manhattan around mile 24, Schnipper’s in Midtown is a solid choice for an In-N-Out-style burger. Their Schnipper’s Classic, starting at $8, offers a perfectly sized patty with fresh veggies and a tangy sauce, often compared to In-N-Out for its balance of flavors and price. It’s a quick stop for spectators near Times Square. After your meal, explore Korean BBQ options with the NYC Best Korean BBQ Restaurants Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Affordable, fresh, and the right size for a quick bite.
• Pro Tip: Add bacon for a twist In-N-Out doesn’t offer.

5. Shake Shack – Upper West Side (Near the Finish Line in Central Park)

Location: 366 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024

Celebrate crossing the finish line in Central Park with a burger at Shake Shack on the Upper West Side. While pricier than In-N-Out at $7 for a ShackBurger, it’s often cited as NYC’s closest equivalent, with fresh, never-frozen beef and a soft bun. It’s a fitting reward for runners and spectators alike. After your burger, relax at a nearby spa with the NYC Spa Clubs Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Fresh beef, simple menu, and a cult following.
• Pro Tip: Order a shake to celebrate your Marathon achievement.

6. The York – East Village (Near Mile 9 in Brooklyn)

Location: 138 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003

Another East Village gem near mile 9, The York is a lesser-known spot often praised for its In-N-Out-like burgers. Their cheeseburger, priced at $8, features fresh veggies, a thousand island dressing, and a casual vibe that mirrors In-N-Out’s appeal. It’s a great stop for spectators in the area. After your meal, explore free activities with the NYC Free & Cheap Events Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Fresh ingredients, affordable price, and a cool, casual atmosphere.
• Pro Tip: It’s a great spot for a quick bite before heading back to the route.

7. 8-Bit Bites – Lower East Side (Near Mile 8 in Brooklyn)

Location: 38 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002

Near mile 8 as the Marathon passes through Brooklyn, 8-Bit Bites in the Lower East Side offers a solid In-N-Out-style burger for $7. Their burgers feature a thousand island-ish dressing and fresh veggies, giving that familiar In-N-Out taste. The retro vibe adds a fun twist for Marathon spectators. After your burger, play a game of pickleball to keep the energy up with the NYC Pickleball Courts Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Similar dressing and fresh toppings at a budget price.
• Pro Tip: Their fries are a great match for a post-burger snack.

8. Donovan’s Pub – Woodside (Near Mile 15 in Queens)

Location: 57-24 Roosevelt Ave, Woodside, NY 11377

At mile 15 in Queens, Donovan’s Pub in Woodside offers a juicy, In-N-Out-style burger for $9. Their half-pounder is perfectly cooked with melted cheese and a charred bun, capturing the simplicity and quality In-N-Out is known for. It’s a great stop for spectators in the area. After your meal, explore outdoor dining options with the NYC Outdoor Dining Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Fresh, simple, and satisfying with a neighborhood feel.
• Pro Tip: Pair it with their thick-cut fries for a hearty meal.

9. Burger Joint – Flatiron (Near Mile 24 in Manhattan)

Location: 33 W 8th St, New York, NY 10011

Near mile 24 in Manhattan, Burger Joint in Flatiron offers a no-frills burger for $8 that’s often compared to In-N-Out for its simplicity and fresh ingredients. Tucked behind a curtain in the Parker Hotel, this spot has a hidden gem vibe that’s perfect for a quick Marathon bite. After your burger, grab a slice nearby with the NYC Pizza Near Me Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Classic, fresh burgers in a casual setting.
• Pro Tip: It’s cash-only, so bring some bills!

10. Mo’s Burgers – Harlem (Near Mile 22 in Manhattan)

Location: 2257 1st Ave, New York, NY 10029

Another Harlem option near mile 22, Mo’s Burgers is a local spot often cited as an In-N-Out alternative. Their cheeseburger, starting at $6, offers fresh toppings and a simple patty that captures the In-N-Out spirit. It’s a great stop for spectators cheering in Harlem. After your meal, unwind at a rooftop bar with the NYC Rooftop Bars and Happy Hours Directory.

• Why It’s In-N-Out Style: Affordable, fresh, and a local favorite.
• Pro Tip: Try their half fruit punch, half lemonade drink for a refreshing twist.

Explore More Dining Options with Our Directory

Craving more burger spots or other dining options during the Marathon? Our NYC Diners Directory is your go-to resource for finding classic diners and burger-adjacent spots across the city. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a sit-down meal, this directory has you covered.

Tips for Grabbing a Burger During the NYC Marathon

Here’s how to make your burger stops during the NYC Marathon 2025 seamless:

• Time Your Stops: The Marathon starts early, with the first wave at 8 AM—plan your burger break around your cheering or running schedule.
• Choose Quick Spots: Opt for places like 7th Street Burger or Petey’s for fast service to get back to the route quickly.
• Stay Prepared: Use the NYC Emergency Services & Healthcare Directory to ensure you’re ready for a full day of Marathon activities.

Final Thoughts: Share Your NYC Marathon Burger Stop

The NYC Marathon 2025 is a celebration of endurance, community, and, of course, great food. While In-N-Out Burger may not be in NYC, these In-N-Out style burgers in NYC—from 7th Street Burger in the East Village to Harlem Shake in Harlem—will satisfy your cravings along the Marathon route. Whether you’re a runner refueling after 26.2 miles or a spectator cheering from the sidelines, these spots offer the best burgers in NYC during Marathon 2025. Share your Marathon burger stop on social media, tag your friends, and let us know your favorite spot! Use our directories to plan your Marathon day—whether it’s more dining, a rooftop drink, or a relaxing spa visit, NYC has it all.

Where’s your go-to burger spot during the NYC Marathon? Drop your recommendations in the comments below, and follow us on Twitter/X for more NYC event guides!